« DOH! No More | Main | El Cachorro: Tacos al Vapor »
August 22, 2007
The Trees of Guadalajara

Pruned Tree, Chapalita Sur
It seems like in Mexico, trees are the enemy, as if they are to be feared, avoided, and whenever possible, hacked apart until they are barely alive. This might not be the philosophy throughout the entire country - Mexico City does not seem to share the maniacal tendency to slice and dice their trees - but in our neck of the woods, any time any part of any tree gets within a meter of power lines, phone lines, fences or buildings, out come the men with chainsaws to remove not only the limb that threatens to offend, but all the main limbs. It is as if the whole tree is being punished for its impertinence in trying to grow.

Pruned Tree, Chapalita Sur
Although the cutters seem ready at a moment's notice to lob off all the limbs of a tree, conversely they seem hesitant in their slaughter once they have set to it. One rarely sees a tree cut off at the bottom of the trunk. Instead, they leave the center of the tree standing, stripped of all branches and foliage, leaving only segments of the limbs, like a deciduous Venus de Milo.

Pruned Tree, Chapalita Sur
This poor specimen below stands across from our apartment building. It provided nice shade for the woman that sells tacos every weekday on the corner, but the branch on the far right began to grow too near the power lines that you can see in the shot. Even though it was the only branch that threatened to come anywhere near the wires, all the limbs of the tree were cut off.
I walked outside one day to wait for my cab, and I saw the crew of three men starting to dismantle the whole thing. By the time I returned from my errands, this is all that was left.

Pruned Tree, Chapalita Sur
Nobody seems to know why they cut trees like this in Guadalajara. Nobody seems to find it attractive. Everyone I have talked to finds it ugly, and none can explain the logic behind stripping trees down so severely but not removing them entirely.

Pruned Tree, Chapalita Sur
There are many neighborhoods in Guadalajara that have no trees whatsoever. Apart from little ornamental tokens here and there and a couple in Plaza San Francisco, the centro histórico and surrounding neighborhoods have no trees. Starting around Avenida Federalismo as you head west from the downtown along Avenida Vallarta, you start to see a few more here and there. Parque de los Colomos has a lot of trees, but it is clearly set apart from the ritzy, tree-free residential areas that surround it. It is as if it were a tree ghetto where trees are tolerated and not as viewed as threatening as long as they are kept isolated in a self-contained area.

Pruned Tree, Chapalita Sur
A shopping complex for Wal-Mart and Sam's Club near Plaza Galerías has a few ficuses littered about throughout the enormous parking lot. On the hot days before the rainy season comes, when the sun blazes in the sky and there is little breeze to cool things down, customers treasure the little islands of shade created by those trees in that sea of baking asphalt. All the spots in the shade fill up before any others. Even if people have to walk from the far edge of the parking lot where there are no other cars, they will take park in the shady spots to keep their cars cool.
So why do tapatios not plant more trees, and why do they do this to the trees that already exist?

Pruned Tree, Chapalita Sur
I have heard it argued that after the trees are savaged like this, that new growth will start again and the tree will soon be just as leafy as it was before. This is a load of hogwash.
To the extent that the leaves do come back, they come back as shown in the photo below. A few twigs grow out of the side of the hacked off branches and start to put out leaves. This is hardly as leafy as the tree was before, and it results in a weird combination of poofy/gangly, like a recently trimmed French poodle.

Pruned Tree, Chapalita Sur
After a few years of struggling back, it might get to where it looks like this.

Pruned Tree, Chapalita Sur
This is an example of a tree that survived pruning and managed to slip under the radar thus far. It's safe, but for how long?

Pruned Tree, Chapalita Sur
Others are not so lucky.

Pruned Tree, Chapalita Sur
The ones that do not make it are left to stand like this for years on end. This one, across the street diagonally from our apartment, has been like this since we moved in, coming up on two years now. Who knows how long it stood like this before we got here?

Pruned Tree, Chapalita Sur
Posted by crispy at August 22, 2007 03:32 PM
Comments
That is so sad!
Posted by: Carol at August 23, 2007 10:27 AM
Damn trees, using up ALL my Carbon Dioxide!!!
Posted by: Akira at August 23, 2007 03:08 PM
Sweet mother of gravy.
I guess it's not as bad as killing puppies or fetuses, but still abominable.
Very silly.
Posted by: Mark Allen at August 23, 2007 06:00 PM
They butcher the trees the same way here where we live (Guaymas, Sonora); except that they seldom use chainsaws. Mostly they use their machetes and the trees really end up looking terrible. Surprisingly in about 2 months most of them look OK, not as good as they did; but OK. The first time I saw them do this I was horrified, our landlord just shrugged his shoulders and told me that the trees would be fine and they were. Go figure.
[crispy says: Thanks for your comments! I have to note though that the tree across the street from our apartment building (the 4th one down) got hacked at least three months ago, and the above photo shows how it looks today. I wouldn't describe that one as okay looking. Of all the above photos, that's the most recently cut tree. So even if the trees get back to looking okay in Guadalajara, it takes a lot longer than two months.]
Posted by: brenda at August 24, 2007 09:04 AM
That's cuz chainsaws are more efficient than machetes.
Posted by: Mark Allen at August 24, 2007 11:09 PM